Blog

Why Caregivers Cancel on Holidays and What You Can Actually Do About It?

Ah, the holidays. A time for cheer, hot cocoa, and… scheduling chaos for healthcare providers. If you’ve ever had a caregiver cancel right before a major holiday, you know the drill  frantic phone calls, last-minute scrambling, and an empty shift that should’ve been covered. Why does this always happen? And more importantly, what can you actually do about it?

We’re Always Short on Holidays!

Dr. Smith: “I’ve had three caregivers cancel Christmas morning in the past five years. It’s like a holiday curse.”

Dr. Joe: “We dealt with the same thing. The trick? Stop expecting the schedule to work like any other week. Holidays need their own plan.”

Dr. Smith: “I’ve tried early scheduling, bonuses, even guilt trips. Still doesn’t work.”

Dr. Joe: “We stopped playing whack-a-mole and built in a hybrid model. Some coverage came from remote support roles  scheduling, admin, even intake. Partnering with a service like Staffingly helped us stay ahead.”

Dr. Smith: “Remote coverage? Over the holidays?”

Dr. Joe: “Yup. You’d be surprised what you can offload when you’re not trying to plug holes 24/7.”

Key Takeaways

1. Plan Early – Start locking in holiday schedules as early as possible. The more notice you give your caregivers, the better.

2. Offer Meaningful Incentives – It’s not just about money. Think about what your caregivers value  gift cards, extra time off, or a flexible schedule.

3. Rotate Holiday Coverage – Don’t make the same people work every holiday. Set up a fair system so that no one is stuck covering all the shifts.

4. Have a Backup Plan – Emergencies happen, so always have a contingency plan in place. Consider remote support for non-clinical tasks to ease the burden on your team.

5. Leverage Staffingly – Outsource non-clinical tasks like scheduling and admin to remote support services, so your clinical staff can focus on care.

The Reality No One Talks About

Holiday coverage is notoriously difficult. Why?

• Family time takes priority — just like it does for everyone else.

• Burnout is real — and holidays can feel like the final straw.

• No incentives — many caregivers don’t see enough reason to sacrifice their own traditions.

Some call in last-minute. Others ghost. A few give plenty of notice — but it still leaves you scrambling.

Why It Keeps Happening and Why It Feels Worse Every Year?

It’s not just about the holidays. It’s about the staffing model buckling under pressure. When you already run lean, any time off — especially during the holidays — feels like a gut punch.

• According to the National Association for Home Care & Hospice, over 56% of providers report holiday staffing as their number one seasonal stressor.

• Last-minute no-shows rise nearly 30% during peak holidays, especially when there’s no structured backup system in place.

Soft Fixes That Actually Work

Here’s what some smart operators are doing to get ahead of the holiday storm:

1. Pre-schedule holiday coverage weeks in advance — and be transparent about it.

2. Offer meaningful incentives — not just pizza or “double time,” but time off credits or gift cards that matter.

3. Create rotating holiday responsibilities — so the same caregivers don’t always draw the short straw.

4. Have a hybrid backup model — offload non-clinical tasks like admin, scheduling, intake, and billing to trained remote staff.

Enter Staffingly: Your Holiday Secret Weapon

Staffingly helps you fill the gaps that cause holiday panic. Instead of scrambling to find a caregiver at 5:30 a.m. on New Year’s Day, Staffingly’s remote healthcare professionals keep essential workflows running:

• Appointment scheduling, follow-ups, and cancellations

• Patient intake and records management

• Insurance verification and billing support

• After-hours messaging and triage

By taking these responsibilities off your in-house team, your remaining caregivers can focus on care — not chaos.

And Yes It Saves You Money

By outsourcing non-clinical roles through Staffingly, many clinics and agencies report:

• Up to 70% in cost savings

• Fewer last-minute cancellations due to better-managed workflows

• Lower staff burnout — especially when they know backup support exists

What Did We Learn?

We learned that holiday caregiver scheduling can be a major source of stress for healthcare providers, with cancellations, burnout, and personal commitments often leading to last-minute scrambling. However, there are practical ways to alleviate this frustration. Planning well in advance, offering meaningful incentives, and rotating holiday shifts can all help ensure that staff is committed and the workload is evenly distributed. Additionally, having a backup plan for unexpected cancellations, such as utilizing remote support for non-clinical tasks, can keep operations running smoothly. Ultimately, by implementing these strategies and leveraging services like Staffingly for administrative support, healthcare providers can minimize chaos and focus on providing quality care during the holiday season.

What People Are Asking?

1. Why do caregivers cancel on holidays?
Caregivers may cancel due to personal commitments, family time, burnout, or lack of sufficient incentives to work during the holiday season.

2. How can I prevent caregiver cancellations during the holidays?
Plan schedules early, offer meaningful incentives, rotate holiday shifts fairly, and have a backup plan in place.

3. What are effective incentives for caregivers around the holidays?
Consider offering gift cards, extra time off, or flexible scheduling instead of just monetary bonuses to make caregivers feel appreciated.

4. How can remote support help during the holidays?
Remote support can handle non-clinical tasks like scheduling, admin, and patient intake, allowing your in-house team to focus on patient care.

5. How can Staffingly assist with holiday scheduling?
Staffingly provides remote support for administrative tasks, helping to ensure smooth operations even when caregivers take time off during the holidays.