Blog

How to Obtain Insurance Prior Authorization for Insulin Lispro with Simply Healthcare Medicare?

Insurance Company Overview: Simply Healthcare Medicare

Let’s start with a bit about Simply Healthcare Medicare. They’re part of the broader Medicare network and offer specialized Medicare Advantage plans. Simply Healthcare focuses on quality care for senior members while balancing cost control for high-cost medications. They, like many other Medicare providers, have stringent prior authorization (PA) policies to manage costs while ensuring members get necessary treatments. If you’re working with expensive treatments like Insulin Lispro, Simply Healthcare often asks for prior authorization. This way, they can verify the medical necessity and explore if any less expensive, effective alternatives are available before covering the medication.

For this particular case, the medication in question was Insulin Lispro—a fast-acting insulin commonly used to manage blood sugar levels in individuals with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus, particularly post-meal glucose spikes. Simply Healthcare’s requirements were specific: they wanted to see if this medication was truly needed over other available options like long-acting insulins.

Why the Prior Authorization Was Needed for Insulin Lispro

Insulin Lispro is a rapid-acting insulin, often prescribed to help manage blood sugar spikes right after meals. For people with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus, particularly when glucose levels fluctuate significantly post-meal, a fast-acting insulin like Lispro can make a big difference. However, Simply Healthcare required a PA due to its high cost and the availability of alternative insulins.

The endocrinologist had prescribed Insulin Lispro for this patient, who had been diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus without complications (ICD-10 code E11.9). The prescription was for a 30-day supply of 10 milliliters. To get approval, we needed to provide evidence that other insulin types were unsuitable for the patient, specifically focusing on the patient’s failed trials with alternatives and the medical need for Insulin Lispro’s specific effects on post-meal glucose control.

Step-by-Step Breakdown of the Prior Authorization Process

Here’s how I tackled this PA request, step-by-step. As a Prior Authorization Specialist, the goal was to ensure everything needed was provided upfront and in the right way to expedite approval.

Step 1: Submitting the Initial PA Request

I began by filling out the Simply Healthcare Medicare Electronic Prior Authorization Form. It required several details, including:

• Patient demographics and prescriber details: The endocrinologist overseeing this patient’s care for Type 2 Diabetes.
• Medication specifics: Insulin Lispro, requested at 100 units per milliliter, for a total of 10 milliliters over a 30-day period.
• Diagnosis code: E11.9, indicating Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus without complications.

The process can feel like filling out an endless questionnaire, but each piece is crucial to helping the insurance company understand why this medication was necessary.

Step 2: Addressing Clinical Questions from Simply Healthcare

Shortly after submitting, Simply Healthcare Medicare followed up with several clinical questions. These questions, aimed at confirming the necessity of Insulin Lispro, are typical and designed to ensure the right medication choice. Here’s what they asked:

1. Has the patient tried any long-acting or intermediate-acting insulin agents? I answered no, explaining that the patient’s glucose management needed fast-acting insulin to handle post-meal spikes, something long-acting insulins can’t address effectively.
2. Is the PA for initial or continuation of therapy? I confirmed this as an initial therapy request.
3. Is this an electronic prescription request? Yes, it was.

These questions were designed to confirm why Insulin Lispro was chosen over other options. Providing precise responses helped demonstrate why the fast-acting insulin was medically necessary.

Step 3: Supporting Documentation Submission

The next step was compiling and submitting the supporting documentation, which was essential for making our case. I included:

• Patient progress notes: This showed the patient’s history with Type 2 Diabetes, including the ups and downs with previous treatments and blood sugar fluctuations.
• Endocrinologist’s prescription summary: This document detailed the patient’s trials with other treatments and why those didn’t work, explaining the rationale for selecting Insulin Lispro.
• Evidence of therapeutic failure with preferred medications: This included documentation proving why the patient couldn’t achieve satisfactory blood glucose control with other insulins.

This additional information was crucial, helping to justify the switch to Insulin Lispro as necessary, not simply convenient.

Step 4: Final Submission and Follow-Up

With all the necessary information submitted, I made sure to follow up on the PA status. Consistent follow-up is key—sometimes insurers need gentle nudges to prioritize a case. Within a few business days, Simply Healthcare Medicare approved the PA, greenlighting Insulin Lispro for the patient’s treatment. This approval allowed the endocrinologist to proceed with the prescribed insulin and relieved the patient from worrying about affording the medication.

ICD and CPT Codes Explained

Let’s quickly cover the significance of ICD and CPT codes in this case.

• ICD-10 code E11.9: This code indicates Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus without complications. The ICD (International Classification of Diseases) code provides a standardized way for Simply Healthcare to recognize the diagnosis.
• CPT code for Insulin Lispro administration: While Simply Healthcare didn’t require a CPT code in this case, they sometimes do for other medications. CPT (Current Procedural Terminology) codes detail the specific service or treatment, helping the insurer understand exactly what’s planned for the patient.

These codes streamline the process for insurance evaluators, giving them a clear idea of the patient’s needs and the exact care they’re receiving.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why is prior authorization required for Insulin Lispro?

Simply Healthcare requires prior authorization for high-cost medications like Insulin Lispro to verify that they’re necessary and to check if less costly alternatives have been tried. This helps control healthcare costs while ensuring patients get the best treatment.

What documentation do I need for a PA request for insulin?

Typically, you need the patient’s medical history, diagnosis, prescription details, and evidence of therapeutic failure with preferred alternatives. Simply Healthcare also requires responses to specific clinical questions.

How long does the PA process take?

The timeline can vary, but with Simply Healthcare, you can expect a decision within 5–7 business days if all documentation is submitted promptly. Following up can sometimes expedite the process.

What happens if the PA is denied?

If denied, you can appeal the decision. This often involves providing additional details or evidence, possibly even a peer-to-peer review where the healthcare provider discusses the case with a medical director from the insurance company.

What Did We Learn?

• Thorough Documentation is Key: The PA process is documentation-heavy, but having complete medical records and clinical notes can make the difference between approval and denial.
• Quick Responses to Clinical Questions Matter: Addressing insurer queries promptly helps keep the process moving, reducing delays and showing the urgency of the patient’s needs.
• Knowing Medication Alternatives is Essential: Explaining why other medications won’t work for a patient’s specific needs is crucial for validating the choice of medication like Insulin Lispro.

Conclusion

Handling PAs for high-cost medications can feel complex, but with the right approach, it’s manageable. At Staffingly Inc., we specialize in taking on the heavy lifting of prior authorizations, ensuring that healthcare providers can focus on what matters most—caring for their patients. By outsourcing tasks like insurance verifications, PAs, and medical data entry to us, you can save time and significantly cut staffing costs, sometimes by up to 70%.

If you’re a healthcare provider looking to streamline your PA processes, we’d love to help. Reach out to Staffingly, Inc. at (800) 489-5877 or contact dan@staffingly.com. Learn how we can assist your practice with Prior Authorization, Insurance Verification, Virtual Medical Receptionists, and more.