Blog

Can Having Two Health Insurances Cause More Problems Than Benefits?

“I’ve been on SSDI and Medicare Advantage (Cigna) for seven years. It’s my secondary insurance. My primary is Blue Cross Blue Shield from my husband’s job. It worked well for a while, but now it feels like having both may be more of a hindrance than anything.”

This statement from a Reddit discussion captures the ongoing confusion surrounding Medicare Advantage versus supplemental insurance. Many patients are unsure whether maintaining two policies is beneficial or unnecessarily complicated.

Across healthcare communities, both patients and providers share frustrations about visit limits, billing overlaps, and denied claims. As one physician put it, “Medicare Advantage is a diluted version of Medicare. It is not Medicare. It has different rules.”

Understanding these differences has become crucial for both patients and the healthcare professionals who support them.

The Dual Coverage Dilemma: When Two Insurances Conflict

The original Reddit poster explained, “It worked for me for a while, but now it feels like having both insurances may be more of a hindrance than anything.”

Dual insurance coverage can sound ideal but often creates administrative challenges. The patient reported that Blue Cross Blue Shield covers only 20 physical therapy visits, and the Medicare Advantage plan refused to pay beyond that.

Providers often see similar conflicts in their clinics. While Original Medicare typically covers ongoing therapy when medically necessary, Medicare Advantage plans may stop coverage based on utilization review.

This creates confusion for both providers and patients who are unsure which payer is responsible once limits are reached. It also increases administrative work for clinic staff trying to manage coordination between two insurers.

Understanding the Difference: Medicare Advantage Is Not Original Medicare

One healthcare professional on Reddit emphasized, “Medicare Advantage is a diluted version of Medicare. It is not Medicare. It has different rules.”

Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans are offered by private insurance companies. While they may include extra benefits such as vision or dental, they also bring network restrictions and authorization requirements that Original Medicare does not have.

A moderator in the discussion clarified, “You can change your Medicare Advantage plan, but almost all of them require prior authorization. That can limit the number of visits if the insurance company doesn’t think they are medically necessary.”

Healthcare professionals consistently report that these added requirements lead to treatment delays, extra paperwork, and appeals that strain clinic resources.

More Predictable but With Cost Gaps

A moderator offered a practical comparison:
“You could drop Cigna and go back to straight Original Medicare parts A & B and keep your employer plan. When your 20 appointments are up, Original Medicare could cover additional appointments if they’re medically necessary. Original Medicare pays 80 percent, and you would be responsible for 20 percent.”

For patients requiring ongoing therapy, Original Medicare may provide more consistent coverage. However, without a supplemental plan, patients are responsible for 20 percent coinsurance after each service.

This cost can be manageable for some but significant for others on fixed incomes. The moderator also warned, “If you drop Cigna, make sure your employer insurance has creditable drug coverage. If it doesn’t, you’ll need to sign up for one to avoid future penalties.”

Healthcare professionals highlight the importance of proactive verification before any coverage change.

Flexibility with Cost Considerations

Another Reddit user suggested, “Maybe a Medicare supplement would be best and ditch the MAPD.”

Supplements, or Medigap plans, help cover the costs that Original Medicare does not. However, not everyone qualifies or can afford them. One commenter noted, “Most people on SSDI find Medicare Supplements either unavailable or prohibitively expensive, so they choose Medicare Advantage.”

Medigap plans remove visit restrictions and prior authorization barriers but require monthly premiums. For younger individuals on disability, some states do not require insurers to offer these plans, leaving Medicare Advantage as the only option.

Healthcare professionals often recommend consulting with an enrollment specialist before making major coverage changes.

Every Policy Has Its Own Limitations

A moderator summarized the complexity well:
“You would have to compare the benefits with your current employer plan and with the Cigna plan to see if having straight Cigna would be better.”

This shows that Medicare Advantage plans are not uniform. Each insurer sets its own limits, networks, and authorization requirements.

Healthcare teams spend considerable time verifying benefits and clarifying patient eligibility. Without clear communication, claim errors and denials increase, slowing down payment cycles.

Many healthcare professionals now use dedicated verification support to handle these variations efficiently.

Insurance Verification Specialists: Preventing Coverage Confusion

Healthcare professionals report that the most effective way to reduce delays is through insurance eligibility and verification specialists.

These specialists confirm which plan is primary, what benefits apply, and what visit limits exist before care is provided. This ensures smoother billing and faster approvals.

Staffingly’s Insurance Eligibility Verification teams integrate with EMR systems such as Epic, Cerner, and Athenahealth to manage verifications remotely.

Specialists are located in India and Pakistan, with additional staff from the Philippines for expanded time zone coverage. Many hold medical or administrative degrees and understand both clinical terminology and payer systems.

This service helps healthcare teams avoid confusion and focus on direct patient care.

Prior Authorization Specialists: Managing Complex Requirements

In the Reddit discussion, healthcare professionals emphasized that prior authorizations have become a major burden. One moderator wrote, “Almost all Medicare Advantage plans require a prior authorization.”

Staffingly’s Prior Authorization Specialists handle these processes from start to finish. They gather clinical documents, submit forms, and follow up until approval is secured.

Their work reduces the administrative load on in-house staff and ensures no patient’s care is delayed due to paperwork.

All specialists operate under HIPAA, SOC 2, and ISO 27001 standards, ensuring strict data protection.

With pricing that starts at $9.50 per hour (under $2,000 monthly) compared to $6,000 locally, healthcare organizations can save significant costs without sacrificing compliance or quality.

AI and Human Oversight: Smarter Medicare Coordination

Automation helps identify potential coverage conflicts and alerts staff when policies overlap. However, AI systems require human management to ensure accuracy.

Virtual medical assistants monitor these systems, verify alerts, and correct data in real time. This combination of AI efficiency and human expertise ensures that claims are processed accurately.

Healthcare professionals report that this AI plus human model significantly improves payer coordination, reduces denials, and enhances overall workflow efficiency.

Simplify Medicare Coordination

Healthcare professionals say it best: “It worked for me for a while, but now it feels like having both insurances may be more of a hindrance than anything.”

If your healthcare practice is dealing with complex payer rules, prior authorization delays, or insurance coordination issues, there is a better way.

15-Day Workflow Optimization Trial – No Setup Fees

✓ Insurance Verification Specialists – Confirm coverage, payer order, and visit limits
✓ Prior Authorization Experts – Manage approvals, documentation, and renewals
✓ AI-Assisted Oversight – Maintain accurate coordination across multiple payer systems

Virtual assistants from India and Pakistan, with additional support from the Philippines, bring strong clinical and administrative expertise to improve operational efficiency.

HIPAA-compliant. Healthcare-specialized. Starting at $9.50 per hour. Under $2,000 monthly compared to $6,000 for local staff.

What Did We Learn?

• Dual insurance can create billing and coordination challenges.

• Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare have different coverage rules.

• Supplemental insurance may provide flexibility but can be costly.

• Virtual assistants simplify eligibility checks, authorizations, and payer coordination.

• Combining AI with human expertise improves claim accuracy and reduces errors.

What People Are Asking?

1. Is Medicare Advantage the same as Original Medicare?
No. Medicare Advantage is a private plan with its own rules and restrictions, unlike Original Medicare.

2. Does Medicare Advantage limit physical therapy visits?
Yes, many plans set caps or require prior authorization for continued therapy.

3. What does supplemental insurance cover?
Supplemental plans, or Medigap, cover the 20 percent of costs that Original Medicare does not.

4. How can healthcare teams manage multiple payers more efficiently?
By using dedicated insurance verification and prior authorization specialists who handle payer communication.

5. Are Staffingly services compliant with healthcare regulations?
Yes. All services follow HIPAA, SOC 2, and ISO 27001 standards for patient data protection.

Disclaimer

For informational purposes only; not applicable to specific situations.

For tailored support and professional services

Please contact Staffingly, Inc. at (800) 489 5877

Email: support@staffingly.com

About This Blog: This Blog is brought to you by Staffingly, Inc., a trusted name in healthcare outsourcing. The team of skilled healthcare specialists and content creators is dedicated to improving the quality and efficiency of healthcare services. The team passionate about sharing knowledge through insightful articles, blogs, and other educational resources.