Blog

How to Choose Between Virtual Assistants and Office Staff?

If you’re a healthcare provider—whether you’re running a small private clinic or managing a bustling multi-specialty practice—you’ve probably wondered about the best way to handle the administrative workload. Should you stick to the traditional route of hiring in-house staff, or is it time to explore virtual medical assistants (VMAs)? This is a conversation I’ve had with many of my colleagues, and I’ll walk you through the key differences, benefits, and challenges so you can decide what works best for you.

The Role of Administrative Support in Healthcare

Before we dive in, let’s step back and talk about why this decision matters. Administrative tasks are often the backbone of any healthcare practice. From managing patient records and scheduling appointments to handling insurance verifications and answering phones, these tasks can pile up quickly.

When this administrative burden overwhelms your clinical team, it can lead to burnout, inefficiencies, and even a diminished patient experience. That’s why having the right kind of support in place—whether virtual or in-house—is critical to keeping your practice running smoothly.

Key Takeaways

• Virtual medical assistants (VMAs) provide remote support for administrative tasks and often work for significantly lower costs than in-house staff.
• In-house staff offer physical presence, making them invaluable for hands-on tasks or in-person patient interactions.
• The right choice depends on your practice’s size, budget, workload, and specific needs.

Comparing Virtual Medical Assistants and In-House Staff

1. Cost Efficiency

• Virtual Medical Assistants (VMAs): Virtual assistants are typically more cost-effective than in-house staff. You don’t have to worry about expenses like benefits, office space, or equipment. Most VMAs work through staffing agencies that handle payroll, training, and compliance, saving you time and money.

  A typical VMA costs between $8 and $15 per hour, depending on the level of expertise and services offered. Compared to hiring a full-time employee with a salary, benefits, and overhead costs, this can be a game-changer for smaller practices.

• In-House Staff: In-house staff, while often indispensable for certain roles, come with additional expenses. Salaries, health insurance, retirement benefits, and other perks can quickly add up. On top of that, there are costs for onboarding, training, and ongoing development.

2. Scope of Tasks

• Virtual Medical Assistants: VMAs excel at handling repetitive and time-consuming administrative tasks such as:
  • Appointment scheduling and reminders
  • Medical billing and coding
  • Insurance verification
  • Data entry and maintaining electronic health records (EHRs)
  • Answering phone calls and managing emails

  However, their remote nature means they can’t handle tasks that require physical presence, like patient check-ins, lab work, or assisting during procedures.

• In-House Staff: Your in-house team can handle everything a VMA can, but they’re also essential for tasks requiring on-site attention. For instance:
  • Greeting patients and checking them in
  • Assisting with medical procedures
  • Stocking and managing supplies
  • Providing a warm, personal touch in face-to-face interactions

  If your practice relies heavily on these in-person services, in-house staff are a must.

3. Flexibility and Availability

• Virtual Medical Assistants: VMAs offer unparalleled flexibility. Many virtual assistants can work across different time zones, meaning you can extend your office hours or get administrative work done after hours. This is particularly useful for practices that deal with patients in multiple time zones or want to offer 24/7 phone support.
• In-House Staff: In-house staff typically work during standard office hours. While they can adapt to your practice’s schedule, they may not offer the same round-the-clock flexibility as VMAs.

4. Training and Expertise

• Virtual Medical Assistants: Many VMAs are already trained in healthcare-specific tasks like medical coding, billing, and insurance verification. Agencies that provide VMAs ensure their staff is HIPAA-compliant and often offer continuous training to keep them up-to-date with industry standards.
• In-House Staff: In-house staff bring a personal touch and institutional knowledge that can be invaluable over time. However, you’ll need to invest in training to ensure they’re familiar with your practice’s processes, software, and compliance requirements.

5. Scalability

• Virtual Medical Assistants: One of the biggest advantages of VMAs is scalability. Need extra help during flu season or when patient volumes spike? You can easily adjust the number of hours or add more VMAs without a long hiring process.
• In-House Staff: Scaling up with in-house staff takes more time and resources. Hiring, onboarding, and training new employees can take weeks or even months.

6. Patient Experience

• Virtual Medical Assistants: VMAs can handle patient interactions over the phone or via chat, ensuring prompt responses and seamless communication. However, some patients may miss the warmth of face-to-face interactions.
• In-House Staff: Nothing beats the personal touch of a friendly receptionist or nurse greeting patients as they walk through the door. For practices that prioritize high-touch, in-person care, in-house staff may be essential.

How to Decide Which Option is Right for Your Practice

Choosing between virtual medical assistants and in-house staff isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. Here’s how to assess your practice’s needs:

1. Evaluate Your Budget: If cost is a major factor, VMAs are a clear winner. However, if you have the resources for in-house staff and your practice requires a lot of hands-on support, the investment may be worth it.
2. Consider Your Workload: For practices that deal with a high volume of administrative tasks, VMAs can relieve the burden without requiring additional office space or equipment.
3. Assess Patient Expectations: Do your patients expect a warm, personal touch? In-house staff can provide that face-to-face interaction that virtual assistants simply can’t.
4. Think About Long-Term Growth: If you’re planning to expand your practice, VMAs offer a scalable solution that can grow with you.

What’s the Best Combination?

For many practices, the best solution is a hybrid model. By combining in-house staff with virtual medical assistants, you can enjoy the best of both worlds. For example:

• Use VMAs to handle repetitive administrative tasks, freeing up your in-house team for in-person patient care.
• Lean on VMAs for after-hours support or seasonal surges, while maintaining a core team of in-house staff for day-to-day operations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What tasks can virtual medical assistants (VMAs) handle?

VMAs manage administrative duties like appointment scheduling, insurance verification, billing, EHR updates, and patient follow-ups—but they can’t handle in-person tasks.

2. Are VMAs HIPAA-compliant?

Yes, most are HIPAA-trained, but always verify credentials and the agency’s compliance policies.

3. How much do VMAs cost?

VMAs typically cost $8–$15 per hour, making them more affordable than in-house staff with salaries and benefits.

4. Can VMAs work after hours?

Yes, many offer flexible schedules, including evenings and weekends, for extended coverage.

5. What are in-house staff best for?

In-house staff excel at face-to-face patient care, hands-on tasks, and providing a personal touch during visits.

What Did We Learn?

When it comes to choosing between virtual medical assistants and in-house staff, there’s no universal answer. Each option offers unique advantages depending on your practice’s size, budget, and patient needs. VMAs are an affordable, flexible solution for handling administrative work, while in-house staff provide invaluable hands-on support and a personal touch.

The key is to evaluate your practice’s priorities and find the right balance. And remember, this decision isn’t set in stone. As your practice evolves, so can your approach to staffing.

So, which option is better? The answer lies in what’s best for your patients, your team, and your bottom line.

Disclaimer

The information in our posts is meant to inform and educate both healthcare providers and readers seeking a better understanding of healthcare processes. However, it is not a substitute for professional advice. Insurance requirements, policies, and approval processes can vary widely and change over time. For accurate guidance, healthcare providers should consult directly with insurers or use professional resources, while patients should reach out to their insurance providers or healthcare professionals for advice specific to their situation.

This content does not establish any patient-caregiver or client-service relationship. Staffingly, Inc. assumes no liability for actions taken based on information provided in these posts.

For tailored support and professional services,

please contact Staffingly, Inc. at (800) 489-5877

Email : support@staffingly.com.